HacksilverBuried treasure, catalogued

Brooches: from safety-pin fibulae to Viking thistles

Dress fasteners that changed with every fashion, so they date the hoards they lie in: Roman fibulae, Pictish and Irish penannulars, Viking oval brooches.

Brooches are the archaeologist's clock. Before buttons, almost every cloak and dress was held together with a pin, and the shape of that pin changed with fashion every generation or two, so a brooch can often date a grave or a hoard to within a few decades. Most early European brooches work on the safety-pin principle: a pin held under tension by a coiled spring or swinging on a hinge, closing into a catch. Archaeologists call these fibulae. The earliest, the flat "violin-bow" type, appeared in Mycenaean Greece in the 14th century BC, and in Britain brooches came into common use in the Iron Age, from roughly 600 BC.

The Romans made fibulae by the million in bronze, and a few in silver and gold. In the 3rd century AD the crossbow brooch appeared, with a hinged pin set in a long cross-bar, and gold examples became badges of rank for officials and officers of the later empire. Germanic peoples of the Migration Period wore bow brooches, radiate-headed brooches and gem-set disc brooches, often in pairs at the shoulders; the hoards from Pietroasele and Szilágysomlyó contain jewelled gold brooches of this kind made for royal families.

In Ireland and Scotland the plain open-ring or penannular brooch of the Roman period grew, between about 700 and 900, into some of the finest metalwork of early medieval Europe. The pin hangs from a ring, and on the true penannular there is a gap between the two decorated terminals for the pin to pass through. Scottish and Pictish brooches, such as the twelve buried under the chapel floor on St Ninian's Isle in Shetland, usually keep the gap; Irish brooches like the Tara Brooch close it, making a pseudo-penannular ring. They were made in many pieces of silver, often gilded and set with glass, amber and filigree panels. In Anglo-Saxon England, the fashion was for flat disc brooches, and the six openwork silver brooches from Pentney in Norfolk, made around 800 and buried in the 9th century, are among the best.

The Viking age changed the materials. With silver flooding in, Irish and Scottish smiths made heavy, plainer brooches of solid silver, including the thistle brooch, named after its ball-shaped terminals. Scandinavian women wore a pair of domed oval brooches on the upper chest to hold the straps of their dress, cast in bronze and often gilded. Big silver brooches had obvious bullion value, and fragments of them are common in hacksilver hoards, chopped up to make weight.

In the later Middle Ages, simple ring brooches in gold or silver, often inscribed with mottoes of love or faith, were worn by men and women alike, alongside grander gem-set brooches. Gem-set brooches are among the jewellery hidden by Jewish families in Erfurt and Colmar during the persecutions of 1348-49.

Examples

Sources

Hoards with brooches

25

Winchester Hoard

Two matching sets of near-pure gold jewellery, torcs, brooches and bracelets, made c. 75-25 BC with Mediterranean techniques; found near Winchester, 2000.

Iron Age & classical · England · found 2000

Pietroasele Treasure

A Gothic gold hoard of 22 pieces found by quarrymen in Romania in 1837; twelve survive, including eagle brooches and a runic neck-ring, in Bucharest.

Migration period · Romania · found 1837

Szilágysomlyó Treasure

Found in two parts on one Transylvanian hill (1797, 1889): Roman gold medallions, a chain of 52 pendants and jewelled brooches of a Germanic royal house.

Migration period · Romania · found 1797

Gaulcross Hoard

Pictish silver found in a stone circle near Fordyce in 1838; only three pieces survived until a 2013 dig recovered 100 more, with Roman coins.

Migration period · Scotland · found 1838

Norrie's Law Hoard

Pictish and late Roman silver dug from a Fife cairn around 1819: perhaps 12 kg found, most melted down; about 170 pieces (750 g) survive in Edinburgh.

Migration period · Scotland · found 1819

St Ninian's Isle Treasure

28 Pictish silver objects, including 12 brooches and 8 bowls, found under a cross-marked slab in a Shetland chapel in 1958; buried around AD 800.

Early medieval · Scotland · found 1958

Pentney Hoard

Six silver openwork disc brooches of the early 9th century, dug up by a gravedigger in a Norfolk churchyard in the late 1970s.

Viking age · England · found 1978

Beeston Tor Hoard

49 silver pennies, two Trewhiddle-style brooches and three rings, hidden in a Staffordshire cave around 875 and found by a clergyman caver in 1924.

Viking age · England · found 1924

Hoen Hoard

Norway's largest Viking gold find: about 2.5 kg of neck-rings, arm-rings, coin pendants and beads, dug from a bog at Hokksund in 1834.

Viking age · Norway · found 1834

Bedale Hoard

A gold-inlaid sword pommel, silver neck-rings and 29 ingots, buried in North Yorkshire around 900 and found in 2012. Now in the Yorkshire Museum.

Viking age · England · found 2012

Galloway Hoard

Over 100 objects, more than 5 kg of silver, gold, silk and crystal, buried c. AD 900 in Kirkcudbrightshire and found in 2014. Now in Edinburgh.

Viking age · Scotland · found 2014

Silverdale Hoard

201 pieces of Viking silver in a lead box, buried c. 900 near Silverdale, Lancashire, including a coin naming an unknown king, Airdeconut.

Viking age · England · found 2011

Cuerdale Hoard

About 8,600 pieces of Viking silver, some 40 kg of coins, ingots and chopped jewellery, buried c. 905-910 beside the River Ribble in Lancashire.

Viking age · England · found 1840

Ardagh Hoard

The Ardagh Chalice, a plain bronze cup and four brooches, dug up by two boys in a Limerick ringfort in 1868; buried around AD 900.

Viking age · Ireland · found 1868

Vale of York Hoard

617 silver coins and dozens of ornaments packed into a Carolingian gilt cup, buried in North Yorkshire c. 928 and found by two detectorists in 2007.

Viking age · England · found 2007

Skaill Hoard

Over 100 pieces of Viking silver, about 8 kg, buried c. 950 at Skaill in Orkney and found in a rabbit hole in 1858: Scotland's largest Viking silver hoard.

Viking age · Scotland · found 1858

Vårby Hoard

A 10th-century silver-gilt jewellery hoard found by a boy gathering brushwood near Lake Mälaren in 1871, mixing Scandinavian, Rus' and Islamic ornaments.

Viking age · Sweden · found 1871

Hiddensee Treasure

Sixteen pieces of late 10th-century Viking gold jewellery, about 600 g, washed out of a Baltic beach on Hiddensee by storm floods in 1872-74.

Viking age · Germany · found 1873

Schaprode Hoard (Harald Bluetooth hoard)

About 1.5 kg of Viking-age silver found on Rügen in 2018, with some 100 cross coins of Harald Bluetooth, buried in the 980s as the king fled.

Viking age · Germany · found 2018

Hornelund Hoard

Two gold filigree brooches and a gold arm-ring found by a farmhand near Varde, Jutland, in 1892: the finest Viking goldsmith's work known from Denmark.

Viking age · Denmark · found 1892

Græsli Hoard

2,253 silver coins, hacksilver and a gilt bird brooch found in a potato field in Tydal, Norway, in 1878: the key hoard for King Olav Kyrre's coinage.

Viking age · Norway · found 1878

Colmar Treasure

Rings, brooches and some 300 coins hidden in a wall on Colmar's Jewish street in 1348-49, when the town's Jews were killed in the Black Death persecutions.

Medieval · France · found 1863

Erfurt Treasure

Nearly 28 kg of silver coins, ingots, tableware and jewellery hidden by a Jewish household before the Erfurt massacre of March 1349, found in 1998.

Medieval · Germany · found 1998

Środa Treasure

A royal crown, a Staufer cameo brooch and nearly 8,000 coins, pledged to a Jewish banker in 1348 and found in Środa Śląska in 1985 and 1988.

Medieval · Poland · found 1985

Dune Treasure

122 gold and silver bowls, spoons, chains and belt fittings hidden on a Gotland farm in the 1360s or 1370s, perhaps in 1361; found in 1881.

Medieval · Sweden · found 1881